"Have you called them back?" "Yes, no answer." Every owner with a sales team has had that conversation, and most have wondered whether the call really happened. Without reporting, you are managing on trust and gut feel. With the wrong reporting, you get people gaming whatever number you watch.
This article covers what to report for each setter and closer, how to read the numbers fairly, and how to use them to coach rather than to catch people out.
Two roles, two sets of numbers
Most installers with a sales team split the work in two, even if one person does both:
- Setters (or the office team) contact new leads, qualify them and book appointments.
- Closers (or sales reps) run the survey or sales appointment and win the job.
Their numbers are different, so report them separately.
Setter reporting
Activity
- New leads assigned
- Speed to first contact (median, and worst case)
- Call attempts per lead in the first 48 hours
- Conversations (actual two-way contact by phone, WhatsApp or text)
- Leads with no next action (should be zero)
Results
- Appointments booked
- Lead to appointment rate
- Show rate of their appointments
- Sale rate of their appointments
The last two are the most important lines in the whole report. A setter who books 30 appointments a week looks great until you see that half do not show and few buy. A setter who books 18 that nearly all show and buy is worth more. Measure the setter on what happens after the booking, not only the booking itself.
Closer reporting
Activity
- Appointments sat
- Quotes sent, and how quickly after the appointment
- Follow-up tasks completed on time
- Open quotes with no follow-up in the last seven days
Results
- Close rate on sat appointments
- Average order value
- Sales value per appointment sat (close rate times average order value; the single best comparison between reps)
- Cancellations after signing, within the cooling-off period
- Lost reasons, in categories (price, timing, finance, went elsewhere, no decision)
A simple weekly team view
| Leads | Speed to contact | Booked | Show rate | Sold | Value per lead | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Setter A | ||||||
| Setter B |
| Sat | Close rate | Avg order | Value per sat | Overdue follow-ups | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Closer A | |||||
| Closer B |
The column that tends to shock owners is "overdue follow-ups". It shows, in black and white, who is chasing quotes and who is not.
Read the numbers fairly
Numbers without context create resentment. Before drawing conclusions:
- Compare like with like. A rep covering a rural patch with long drives will sit fewer appointments than one in a city. Leads from a referral convert better than cold Facebook leads. Split results by lead source where you can.
- Look at four weeks, not one. Any rep can have a bad week.
- Check the inputs. If a closer's close rate drops, check whether their setter's show rate and lead quality dropped first.
- Separate effort from skill. Low activity is an effort or capacity problem. High activity with poor results is a skill problem. They need different fixes.
Spot gaming early
Whatever you measure, people will try to hit it. Common patterns:
- Booking anything to hit a booking target. Fix: report show rate and sale rate per setter.
- Logging calls that did not connect as conversations. Fix: use call logs from your phone system or CRM, not manual entry.
- Leaving hard quotes off the pipeline to protect a close rate. Fix: every sat appointment must end with a quote or a lost reason.
- Discounting to close. Fix: watch average order value and margin per rep alongside close rate.
Coach from the numbers
The point of reporting is to help people get better, not to catch them out.
- Weekly one-to-one, fifteen minutes. Start with their numbers on screen.
- Pick one thing to improve. Speed to lead, show rate, follow-up, average order value. Just one.
- Listen to calls. Recorded calls show why a number is what it is. Agree a time each week to review two or three together. Make sure customers are told calls may be recorded, and check your privacy notice covers it.
- Share what top performers do. If one closer has a much higher value per appointment, find out what they do differently and teach it.
- Pay for outcomes. Commission and bonuses should follow sales and shows, not activity alone.
Make it automatic
All of this falls apart if someone has to build the report by hand. Activity and results should come straight from the CRM and phone system: calls logged automatically, appointments booked into diaries, outcomes recorded on each lead. Our Installer Flow reporting shows pipeline and each rep's activity and results on dashboards, alongside cost per lead and cost per sale, so the weekly review is about decisions, not data entry. For the whole-business numbers that sit above the team view, see the 7 numbers every owner should check weekly.
If you do not have a team yet
Many owners do all the selling themselves and are wondering whether to hire. If that is you, the same reporting tells you when it is time: if leads are waiting more than a few hours for contact, or quotes are going out days late, you are the bottleneck. One option is to hire in-house. Another is to bring in a managed team; our sales closing service installs and manages closers who close booked appointments on your behalf, and outsourced setters and closers explains when that makes sense.
If you want to see exactly who is following up and who is not, book a call and we will show you how the reporting would look for your team.
Questions owners ask
How many calls should an appointment setter make a day?
There is no useful universal number. It depends on lead volume, how fresh the leads are and how much admin the role carries. Set the standard from your own data: look at what your best setter does on a good week, check it produces booked appointments that show and buy, and coach others towards that.
How do I stop setters booking poor appointments just to hit a target?
Measure what happens after the booking, not just the booking. Report show rate and sale rate for each setter's appointments. If someone books lots that do not show or never buy, their headline number is hiding a problem. Pay and praise should follow sales, not bookings alone.


