Most trade owners have paid a directory or job site at some point. Some swear by it. Others feel they are renting their own pipeline back every month, paying in quiet spells and competing with three other firms for every job. Both can be true. The real question is not "is Checkatrade good or bad?" but "what does a paying job actually cost me from each source, and what happens to my business if that source disappears?"
This guide shows you how to answer that honestly, and how to build enquiries you own alongside any directory you keep.
How the main platforms charge (in plain terms)
The big UK platforms use three broad models. Exact prices vary by trade and postcode and change often, so check the current trade sign-up page before you commit. As of November 2026, the shapes are:
- Membership listing (Checkatrade). You pay a regular fee to be listed and vetted, and homeowners find you on the site. You pay whether the phone rings or not, and contracts can carry minimum terms.
- Pay to quote or shortlist (MyBuilder). Homeowners post a job, tradespeople express interest, and you pay when you are shortlisted or contacted. The job is seen by several firms.
- Subscription plus per lead (Rated People). A membership fee plus a charge for each lead you accept, with a small number of trades able to take each job.
One detail many owners miss: Checkatrade's own terms say the Checkatrade Group runs several brands, including Rated People. Two "different" subscriptions may be paying into the same group.
The number that matters: cost per paying job
Cost per lead tells you almost nothing. A £15 lead that never answers is more expensive than a £60 lead that books. Work out cost per paying job for each source over at least three months:
- Add up everything you paid that source (membership, lead charges, credits, VAT).
- Count the enquiries it produced.
- Count the jobs that went ahead and were paid for.
- Divide total spend by paying jobs.
Here is a worked example with made-up round numbers, so you can see the shape:
| Source | Spend over 3 months | Enquiries | Paying jobs | Cost per paying job |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Directory membership | £1,800 | 40 | 9 | £200 |
| Pay-per-lead site | £1,200 | 60 | 4 | £300 |
| Own Google Business Profile and referrals | £0 cash, some time | 25 | 11 | Time only |
Then add the time cost. Shared leads mean you are calling fast, quoting more and losing more, so your hours per job won by that route are higher. If you or your estimator spend two hours on every quote, a source that needs ten quotes per job is costing you twenty hours per sale.
Why shared leads close badly
When a job goes to three or four firms at once, the homeowner is in comparison mode before you have said a word. Whoever calls first tends to get the visit. Whoever is cheapest tends to get the job. You cannot build much trust in that setting, and you train yourself to discount.
Which? tells homeowners to get at least three quotes, and possibly more for a big job. That is good advice for them. It also means that on a shared lead, your starting odds are roughly one in three before anything else happens. An enquiry that comes to you because of your reviews, your video or a neighbour's referral starts in a much better place.
When a directory is worth keeping
Directories are not the enemy. They make sense when:
- You are new and have few reviews. The platform's vetting badge does some of the trust work for you.
- You do urgent work (leaks, lockouts, no heating) where homeowners grab the first trusted name they see.
- You need volume while your own channels warm up. Treat it as a bridge with an end date in mind.
- Your cost per paying job from it is genuinely lower than anything else you run. Some trades in some areas find exactly that. Keep it if the numbers say so.
The risk is dependence. If one platform supplies most of your work, a price rise, a change to how leads are shared, or a run of bad placement can empty your diary, and you own none of the audience.
What "owning your leads" actually means
Owned enquiries come to you directly, and you control the channel. The core set for most trades:
- Google Business Profile. Free, and for local trades often the biggest single source. Set it up properly, keep it active and ask every customer for a review. See getting into the map pack.
- Your own reviews. Google reviews belong to your profile, not to a platform you might leave.
- A website that converts. Clear services, real photos, your area, and a short form that asks the right questions. Our website design page covers what that looks like.
- Paid ads you control. Facebook and Instagram ads and Google Ads run to your own landing page, so every enquiry is exclusive to you.
- Past customers. Referrals, repeat work and service reminders. These are usually your cheapest jobs of all.
When we run lead generation for a client, the leads are 100% exclusive: never shared or resold, and one client per area.
A sensible switch-over plan
- Month 1: start tracking source and outcome for every enquiry (a CRM makes this simple, a spreadsheet will do at first). Ask every finished customer for a Google review.
- Months 1 to 3: build or fix your website and Google Business Profile, and start a small, always-on ad campaign to your own landing page.
- Month 3: compare cost per paying job, source by source.
- Months 4 to 6: if owned channels are carrying more of the diary, reduce directory spend in steps. Keep the profile live if it still pays its way.
Windows and doors: growing without bought leads
Glazing is where shared leads hurt most. Buyers expect several quotes, the industry still carries a pushy-sales reputation, and a lead bought by three firms becomes a price fight on day one. Owned channels work well here because glazing sells on visible proof: before-and-after photos of real local homes, short video walk-rounds of a finished install, and a steady flow of reviews. Ads that show a recognisable local street and a real fitter usually do more than any "up to 50% off" banner. Pair that with a referral ask at handover and a follow-up a year later. If the sales reputation is the bigger issue, see shaking off the pushy salesman image.
Conservatory roofs: bought appointments or your own?
Many conservatory roof firms buy pre-booked appointments from lead companies. Sometimes that works, because the appointment arrives in the diary ready to go. Judge it the same way as above: cost per signed contract, not cost per appointment. Pre-set appointments often have lower show and close rates, because the homeowner was sold a visit, not your company. If the numbers hold up, keep buying while you build your own channel. Conservatory roofs suit owned campaigns because the pain is easy to show on camera: a cold, unused room in winter turned into a room the family actually uses. One good video of a real customer's room often outlives months of bought appointments.
The bottom line
A directory is a tool, not a strategy. Keep it while it earns its keep, measure it by paying jobs, and use the time it buys you to build enquiries you own. If you want to see what an owned, exclusive lead flow would look like for your trade and area, book a call with us and we will check whether your area is open.
Sources
Questions owners ask
Is Checkatrade worth it for a new trade business?
It can be, for a while. A new firm with few reviews borrows trust from the directory and gets enquiries it would not get otherwise. Track the cost per paying job from day one, and use the time to collect your own reviews and build your own channels, so the directory becomes a top-up rather than the whole pipeline.
Why do leads from job sites close so badly?
On most pay-per-lead sites the same job goes to several firms at once, so you are one of three or more people calling the same homeowner. The fastest or cheapest usually wins. Some jobs are also tyre-kickers collecting prices. Your close rate on shared leads will normally sit well below enquiries that came to you directly.
Should I cancel my directory membership straight away?
Not until your owned channels are producing enough work to cover the gap. Run both side by side, compare cost per paying job for each, and step down the directory spend only when the numbers show your own enquiries can carry the diary.


